home Feature, Movies This Week in Poorly Argued Criticism

This Week in Poorly Argued Criticism


Man in line: Wait a minute, why can’t I give my opinion? It’s a free country!

Alvy: I mean, d- He can give you- Do you hafta give it so loud? I mean, aren’t you ashamed to pontificate like that?

“Annie Hall” by Woody Allen & Marshall Brickman

Editor’s Note: Supporters of the worldwide Internet community suggest that it is this one marketplace of ideas that makes the web something incredibly strong. Unfortunately, the problem with everyone being able to give their opinion is that people often do. ‘This Week in Poorly Argued Criticism’ is culled from a variety of on-line sources. It’s goal is to not highlight bad reviews. Instead, it is to point out that, no matter how highly praised or critically derided, there is a voice of dissent. If the reader thinks, ‘physician, heal thyself,’ well, let this be a lesson for all.

The following quotes are presented as they were originally posted. The spelling errors and syntax are their own. While they may have been pulled from a larger review, they are as they appeared. The views are not necessarily those of the Lonely Review staff.

The Third Man
I was sooooo disappointed. First the background music that plays all thru this will drive you nuts! then the story is slow moving and not very interesting. It got worse after they opened the grave not exciting, not even very suspenseful. I only watched it to the end because others gave this 5 stars. Did they see the same black and white movie as I did? What were they thinking? Don’t waste your time.

Bonnie & Clyde
This is another 1960’s film designed to subvert american values and culture. Liberals, most notibly Warren Beatty, wereinvolved in the production of it. The message of the film is that crime and violence against society is a great lifestyle.

There is NOTHING in this movie that is worth the constant swearing, the constant violence, the graphic blood.I ended up watching this movie because it was on Some List of movies that were considered “must sees.” Most of the time, the List is right, but not this time. I feel as though I had just been pushed in the slime.

We Are Marshall
I was disappointed in this movie. Not a tear jerker as I had expected and very little relationship building.

If I knew it was going to be subtitles and narrating I would have avoided it all together. First 20 minutes and I just couldn’t watch anymore. The scenes were kind of dull. I do not like foreign films and this one didn’t change my opinion. I go to a movie to relax and enjoy and let it do all the work to entertain me. I don’t want to have to squint and concentrate and rush reading so I can understand the storyline. It just gave me a headache and I was instantly turned off. If I want to read I will get a book. On top of everything else the narrator’s voice(male – creepy old man) sounded so dam annoying. I thought this was going to be a charming feel good movie with a sweet girl and nice accents in some nostalgic little quaint village and interesting people who got a second chance at happiness.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *